Chinese Democracy

6 replies [Last post]
talkToTheHat
talkToTheHat's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/10/2002

http://www.gunsnroses.us/videos/
http://www.gunsnroses.us/

That which the world has got bored of waiting for is finally due out next month. And thanks to friends on LJ, I stumbled on the above site.

Quote:
It don't really matter You're gonna find out for yourself No it don't really matter You're gonna leave this thing to Somebody else

The chorus kinda sums up my reaction. It's not ground breaking. Title track Chinese Democracy sounds like Pitchshifter played at half speed. Only without any of the catchyness. Usually playing the same track 5 times over leaves it stuck in my head for days. Not this one. It just disappears after listening. Must be the DRM Sticking out tongue.

Also on the forthcoming album are Madagasgar and There Was A Time, both sound tired, over-rehearsed and too slow. The best I can say about them is they're only mildly irritating. Madagasgar is soaked in what sounds like synthesised salvation army brass, there's a almost catchy guitar refrain, but it sounds like it's being milked for every drop of emotion by someone who doesn't quite have slash's magic touch. I have this vision of axl screeming "More Emotional, Sadder, Make Me Cry!" until whichever minion currently on the studio side of the revolving door consideres strangling him with a guitar string.

There Was A Time seems lie an exercise in attention defecit, it bounces from mood to mode and riff to riff like axl couldn't decide what he liked before settling down into an epic guitar solo, at least in terms of the pile of peanuts that maybe needed. It sounds like someone desperately trying to impersonate slash, and whilst a fine display of dexterity, it just seems devoid of emotion.

The production is very slick, the drums pop right out of the mix which is a shame because they sound horribly overproduced. Heavy distortion, notched EQ, a little splash of gated reverb. And every fill reminding me of the drum fill button on my Yamaha VSS200.* It sounds really out of place on Chinese Democracy and at times appears to be a pale immitation NIN.

Perhaps I'm expecting too much out of it. I'd like to be able to listen to it without knowing what it was.but even then I don't think I'd like what I've heard so far.

*1988 lo cost keyboard/sampler. 8 bit lo-fi abomination.

__________________

I am not a Legend, I'm just in exile for playing keys.

Gavinge
Gavinge's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/11/2008

I can't believe how many fucking people don't actually know that it ain't even G'N'R anymore and just Axel whoring the name, they think VR and the decade long war of words between Slash and Axel was just for shits and giggles?
Mad.

Stuart_of_the_Damned
Stuart_of_the_Damned's picture
Offline
Joined: 28/06/2005

I on the other hand DO realise this...

...and as I suspected, from what I've heard so far, it's a massive 12 year anti-climax that has culminated in something that sounds over-produced, over-tinkered and sketchy to say the least. But all I see online is people who seem to love it, for some bizzare, nausea-inducing reason...  

__________________

Official RockSoc Pirate 2006
The Power Behind The Throne 2007

Most Likely To Become A Rockstar 2007

Alter-ego Stella - Society Whore 2008

 

Miffy
Miffy's picture
Offline
Joined: 19/03/2005

There will always be those sad people who will like anything with from certain bands just because you're supposed to. I personally don't see the big deal about this, as far as I'm concerned you can say it's Guns N Roses, but when it's just Axl and a group of random people he managed to draft in, it's really not.

 

Then again, I never really liked them in the first place :p 

__________________

Leeds Rock Society's 'Most Overseas Member' 2005-06

Leeds Rock Society General Committee 2006-07

Leeds Rock Society Grand Mistress Of The Ball 2007

Leeds Rock Society Little London Bravery Award 2006-07

darkish_angel87
darkish_angel87's picture
Offline
Joined: 17/10/2005

Gave it a listen on myspace, not bad but not as good as it should be after a 15 year wait, so I won't be buying it.

__________________

"This racist lady won't let us play catch!"

Hunter
Hunter's picture
Offline
Joined: 26/09/2005

It must be said that it's not terrible. However, iven that Axl is piggybacking it on the GnR band name, people will be dissapointed thatit in no way reflects the creativeness that the name implies.

if it were any other band, it would probably find some positive reaction, but wouldn't create such a fuss.

__________________

They say only the good die young. If that works both ways, I'm immortal.
The First Rule of Tautology Club is the first rule of Tautology Club.

BY TOR
BY TOR's picture
Offline
Joined: 15/10/2006

Gavinge wrote:

I can't believe how many fucking people don't actually know that it ain't even G'N'R anymore and just Axel whoring the name, they think VR and the decade long war of words between Slash and Axel was just for shits and giggles?
Mad.

 

I'm pretty sure that everyone in the Rocksoc, even those who aren't GnR fans knows that GnR means just Axl Rose. At one point Dizzy Reed was still involved as well, is he still there or did he finally give up on Axl as well?