Avatar

6 replies [Last post]
Shogg
Shogg's picture
Offline
Joined: 13/02/2008

I'm surprised Daryl hasn't posted something about this but for once, I agree with his comments that came up on my Facebook Wall.

It's basically a Hi-Tech reworking of Dances With Wolves.

I mean, this really isn't the second coming of cinema we've been lead to believe it was.

Yes, it's very pretty and the 3D is acceptable (although to be honest, it was much more effective in both Coraline and Up), but wonderful design, eyecandy and some ok 3D does not make for a good film.

Call me old fashioned, but I'm rather fond of a decent script, a decent plot, stirling performances and something even vaguely original.

Avatar provides none of this.

The story is Dances With Wolves mixed with a bit of FernGully, Aliens and even a bit of Tron! Camerons stock characters make a tiresome return and I found myself checking my watch every few minutes not quite able to believing he'd had the gall to stretch this tosh out for 2 hours and 40 mins.

OKay, *technically* it's very good, I can't deny that, and design-wise it's truly beautiful. But I wanted it to be a good story with good acting, too. For me, this is sort of the essence of a good movie. Avatar failed on these pretty basic terms.

And don't get me started on a movie that suggests we go back to a simply and more eco friendly way of life via the medium of hugely complex technological fripperies.

Btw, if you watch it in 3D, it looks like a cartoon....

Not a favourite movie. Could you guess?

__________________

"A Knife and Fork in a World of Soup"

darkish_angel87
darkish_angel87's picture
Offline
Joined: 17/10/2005

I pretty much agree with everything you say, but I was still completely engrossed in it all the way through, because everything just looks and sounds absolutely magnificent.

__________________

"This racist lady won't let us play catch!"

Shogg
Shogg's picture
Offline
Joined: 13/02/2008

Sorry, I meant if you watch it in 2D it looks like a cartoon.

__________________

"A Knife and Fork in a World of Soup"

Sarah Y
Sarah Y's picture
Offline
Joined: 22/03/2009

I see what you mean with the storyline, it wasn't the most original, it was a beautiful film though, the characters and the design were amazing. I was falling asleep a little near the end though, fight scenes in films always seem to drag on for too long. I think the film could have said the same if it was shorter too.

BY TOR
BY TOR's picture
Offline
Joined: 15/10/2006

I quite enjoyed it but i think the 3D wasn't used to it's full effect.

Someone will probably flame me for this but i can't help but compare it to District 9 which i thought was slghtly more engaging and interesting than this.

Predictability is the name of the game in Avatar.

darkish_angel87
darkish_angel87's picture
Offline
Joined: 17/10/2005

District 9 is the film of the year, no contest

__________________

"This racist lady won't let us play catch!"

Shogg
Shogg's picture
Offline
Joined: 13/02/2008

darkish_angel87 wrote:
District 9 is the film of the year, no contest

Dunno about film of the year, but certainly top five...

Even though I have a natural propensity to hate wobbly cam, District 9 won through for sheer chutzpah!

__________________

"A Knife and Fork in a World of Soup"